Resolving disputes
Mediation
A third person guides the conversation and decides nothing. That is precisely why the result tends to hold afterwards
Key points at a glance
- Mediation is a confidential, structured procedure in which the parties look for an agreement themselves.
- The mediator is neutral and has no power to decide, as the German Mediation Act states.
- Everyone involved can end the mediation at any time.
- Unlike an arbitral award, a mediation binds only what the parties agree themselves.
- If you would rather try to settle a dispute yourself first, there are five steps under resolving conflicts.
In numbers
5
phases in the procedure
from setting the terms to the agreement
0
decision-making power
the mediator has none, by law
2012
Mediation Act in force
since 26 July
Check willingness
First the question whether both sides are willing in principle. Mediation is voluntary, nobody can be obliged to agree.
Find a mediator
The term mediator is not protected, the addition “certified” is. Professional associations, courts and consumer bodies can refer you.
Agree the fee
There are no fixed fees. Best agree the fee and how the costs are shared in writing before the first session.
Sessions
Several meetings over weeks, confidential. Each side can end the mediation at any time without giving a reason.
Check the agreement
The settlement can be recorded in a final agreement. Anyone who comes without their own adviser can have it reviewed externally.
Mediation
- Who decides
- the parties themselves
- Role of the third person
- guides the procedure, without power to decide
- How binding
- only what the parties agree
- Basis
- Mediation Act of 2012
Conciliation
- Who decides
- the parties, based on a recommendation
- Role of the third person
- hears everyone and makes a recommendation
- How binding
- consumers can still go to court afterwards
- Basis
- rules of the body, for consumers the VSBG
Arbitration
- Who decides
- the arbitral tribunal
- Role of the third person
- issues an arbitral award
- How binding
- effect of a final court judgment
- Basis
- arbitration agreement under section 1029 ZPO
- Introduction and basics18 hours
- Procedure and framework40 hours
- Negotiation techniques12 hours
- Conducting conversations18 hours
- Conflict competence12 hours
- Law of mediation6 hours
- Law within mediation12 hours
- Personal competence and stance12 hours
- Origin
- Regulated in Germany by the Mediation Act of 26 July 2012
- Where it is used
- Family, workplace, neighbourhood, business, environmental and building projects
- What it takes
- Several sessions over weeks, voluntary and abandonable at any time
- Third party
- An impartial third person with no power to decide
- Author
- Johannes Max Harms
- Updated

What is mediation?
The German Mediation Act defines mediation as a confidential and structured procedure in which the parties, with the help of one or more mediators, voluntarily and on their own responsibility seek an amicable settlement of their conflict.
The mediator is independent and neutral and has no power to decide. They guide the procedure, make sure both sides are heard, and propose no solution they could then impose.
That sets mediation apart from every procedure in which somebody decides: from a court, from arbitration, and from a manager settling the matter. The parties stay responsible for the result, which is both the strength of the procedure and its precondition.
Confidentiality is protected by law. The mediator and everyone involved in running the process are bound to secrecy. The exceptions are narrow, for instance when disclosure is needed to avert a threat to a child’s welfare, or when the agreement has to be carried out or enforced. The mediator must tell the parties how far this duty reaches.
How does a mediation run?
In five phases: setting the terms, collecting the topics, clarifying the interests behind them, looking for solutions, putting the agreement in writing. The order is not decoration but the core of the method.
The third phase carries the procedure. As long as two sides speak in positions, there is usually a choice between two outcomes. Once the interests behind them are on the table, solutions appear that were not visible before.
A mediation usually runs over several sessions across weeks. It is voluntary, either side can end it at any time, and what is said stays confidential. Those three conditions are why things are said in a mediation that nobody would say in court.
The law also covers the end. The parties can end the mediation at any time, and so can the mediator, for instance when no self-directed communication or agreement is to be expected any more. If they reach an agreement, the mediator works towards both understanding the content and agreeing with full knowledge of the facts. With their consent, the agreement is recorded in a final settlement.
When does mediation fit?
When the parties will go on dealing with each other. Separated parents, neighbours, colleagues, business partners, club boards: a judgment ends the case, not the relationship, and a result both sides carried holds longer in daily life.
It also fits where the matter itself cannot be fully decided in court. Courts decide questions of law; a large part of what people argue about is not a question of law.
And it fits where confidentiality has value. A public procedure produces positions that are hard to clear away afterwards, because somebody heard them.
Where are the limits of mediation?
The most important limit is an imbalance of power. Mediation assumes both sides can state their interests openly. Where one side is dependent, intimidated or affected by violence that is not the case, and a result that merely looks voluntary would be none.
The second limit is voluntariness. Whoever does not want to, need not, and nobody can be obliged to agree. The procedure can end without a result, and then time has passed without anything being decided.
The third limit concerns questions of principle. Where a point of law has to be settled because other cases depend on it, a judgment is the right instrument. Mediation settles one case; it creates no binding interpretation.
The law also covers independence. The mediator must disclose every circumstance that could impair their independence and neutrality, and may then only act with the express consent of the parties. Anyone who has worked for one side in the same matter beforehand may not mediate, nor work for one side in the same matter during or after the mediation.
How do you start with mediation?
With the question whether both sides are open to it in principle. Proposing mediation is itself a signal, and it is more likely to be accepted when it does not have to be read as a concession.
Then comes finding a suitable person. In Germany the title of mediator is not protected, while certified mediator is tied to training under a regulation. Professional associations keep lists, and courts and consumer bodies also refer people.
For smaller matters there are lower thresholds: municipal arbitration boards, conflict offices of associations, trained peer mediators in schools. Not every dispute needs a formal procedure, but every one benefits from an orderly sequence.
The parties choose the mediator themselves; that is in the law. On request, the mediator must tell them about their professional background, training and experience in mediation. Asking this in the preliminary talk is not distrust but part of the process.
What does mediation cost?
There is no fixed price; the parties agree the fee with the mediator themselves. Billing by the hour is common. The German federal association for family mediation (BAFM) gives hourly rates between 80 and 200 euros and notes that a mediation rarely needs more than ten sessions.
Who pays which share is part of the first agreement. The parties often split the fee, but any other split is possible, for example by income. Settling this in the first meeting removes one possible point of dispute right at the start.
Germany has no general legal aid for mediation. The Mediation Act only allows the federal government and the states to run research projects that test funding for people on low incomes. Counselling centres sometimes offer mediation for a donation or free of charge, and some legal expenses insurers cover the costs; the conditions are in the individual policy.
If mediation avoids a lawsuit, the costs of that lawsuit fall away. On top of that, the states may lower or waive court fees when a claim is withdrawn after a mediation. The Court Fees Act and a separate act for family matters provide for this, and state ordinances put it into practice.
How does mediation relate to court proceedings?
A court decides a legal dispute; a mediation does not. Yet the two paths are not separate. The German Code of Civil Procedure obliges the court to seek an amicable settlement of the dispute or of individual points at every stage of the proceedings. As a rule, the oral hearing is therefore preceded by a conciliation hearing.
The court can also suggest that the parties try mediation or another form of out-of-court dispute resolution. If they agree, the court proceedings are suspended in the meantime. Pending litigation does not rule out a mediation.
Within the justice system there is a form of its own. The court can refer the parties to a conciliation judge who does not decide the case and may use every method of dispute resolution, mediation included. The difference to private mediation lies in the setting: the conciliation judge is part of the court, while the parties choose a mediator themselves.
Mediation does not replace legal advice. The Mediation Act requires that parties without professional advice are told they can have an agreement reviewed by outside advisers if needed. Anyone with deadlines or claims to watch therefore clarifies them with a lawyer alongside the process.
The core
Whoever found the solution themselves does not have to enforce it against themselves. That is the whole difference from a judgment.
Sources
- German Mediation Act, section 1, definitions (in German)
- German Federal Agency for Civic Education, wars and conflicts: mediation (in German)
- Mediation Act, section 2, procedure and duties of the mediator (in German)
- Mediation Act, section 4, duty of confidentiality (in German)
- Code of Civil Procedure, section 278, amicable settlement and conciliation judge (in German)
- Code of Civil Procedure, section 278a, mediation and out-of-court dispute resolution (in German)
- Mediation Act, section 3, disclosure duties and restrictions (in German)
- Mediation Act, section 7, research projects and funding of mediation (in German)
- Court Fees Act, section 69b, reduced fees after a mediation (in German)
- Act on Court Fees in Family Matters, section 61a (in German)
- BAFM, federal association for family mediation: costs and funding (in German)
The steps
- Set the termsBoth sides settle with the mediator what the dispute is about, how the procedure runs and what rules apply. Voluntariness and confidentiality are agreed here, not assumed later.
- Collect the topicsEach side names what belongs to the matter. Everything is collected first and without judgement, so that nobody can say afterwards that their concern was never raised.
- Clarify interestsBehind every position comes the question of what it is actually about. This is the step where the task often changes, because interests exclude each other less often than demands.
- Look for solutionsOnly now are options collected, first without evaluation and then examined. The order is deliberate: evaluating too early produces fewer options.
- AgreementThe result is put in writing, concretely enough for implementation to be checkable. Who does what by when, and what happens if it does not happen.
More in this series
- Peer mediation in schoolsSchools, youth work, leisure facilitiesPupils mediate between their peers, by fixed rules and without a teacher at the table. It works better than it first sounds
- The Harvard methodNegotiations of every kind, from pay talks to a neighbourhood disputeNeither hard nor soft but focused on the matter: four principles meant to turn a contest of wills into a shared task
Frequently asked questions about mediation
What does a mediation cost, and who pays for it?
The German Mediation Act sets no fixed fees. The parties agree the fee with the mediator, and they also decide who pays which share. It is best to put this in writing before the first session. The Act provides for public funding only within research projects that the federal government and the states may agree, for people who cannot pay the costs or only in instalments. There is therefore no general right to have the costs covered.
What is the difference between mediation, conciliation and arbitration?
The difference lies in who decides in the end. In mediation the parties reach an agreement themselves; the mediator guides the conversation and decides nothing. In conciliation a conciliation body hears all sides and makes a recommendation the parties can accept. In arbitration an arbitral tribunal decides, which the parties agreed on beforehand in an arbitration agreement. Under section 1055 of the German Code of Civil Procedure its award has the effect of a final court judgment between the parties.
Is an agreement reached in mediation binding?
It is as binding as the parties make it. With their consent the agreement can be recorded in a final settlement. The mediator has to make sure both sides understand its content and has to tell parties without their own advisers that they can have the agreement checked externally. If it is to be enforceable, there are separate routes, for example a settlement between lawyers under section 796a of the Code of Civil Procedure, when both sides are represented and submit to immediate enforcement.
Who may call themselves a certified mediator?
The German Mediation Act does not regulate the title mediator, but it does regulate the addition “certified”. Only someone who has completed training under the ordinance on the training of certified mediators may use it. This includes a course of at least 130 hours of attendance, of which up to 40% may take place virtually, and five supervised mediations within three years of the course. Only then does the training institution issue the certificate. Further training remains mandatory afterwards.
What is the aim of a mediation?
The Act describes it in one sentence: the parties voluntarily and on their own responsibility seek an amicable settlement of their conflict. The German Federal Agency for Civic Education adds what matters in the procedure: clarifying the interests and needs behind entrenched positions and working out solutions independently. Because the mediator does not propose solutions of their own, the people involved own the result. The aim is not a ruling on right and wrong but an arrangement both sides can live with.
Can a mediation be stopped?
Yes, at any time. Section 2 of the German Mediation Act allows the parties to end the mediation without giving reasons. The mediator can also end it, in particular when they no longer expect self-responsible communication or an agreement. Stopping does not rule out other routes, such as conciliation or court proceedings. What was discussed in the mediation stays protected, because under section 4 the mediator is bound to confidentiality.
From a procedure to a mission of your own
Every one of these methods was developed by people who had a dispute in front of them and wanted to handle it differently. The same stance is what it takes on a small scale: in a neighbourhood, a school, a club.
Find your peace mission